Calm blue-green bay water beside a palm-lined seawall and the cropped balconies of an upscale Miami island condominium.

What a Brickell Key Condo Is Worth While the Mandarin Rises

On Sunday, April 12, 2026, the former 23-story Mandarin Oriental hotel at 500 Brickell Key Drive came down in a controlled implosion. Its six-story garage came down with it. Less than six months later, on October 1, Swire Properties announced it had broken ground on The Residences at Mandarin Oriental, Miami. Mandarin Oriental dated its own shovel-in-ground ceremony October 6. That construction site now holds the highest condo price ever recorded on mainland Miami. The 1980s, 1990s and 2000s towers around it sell for a fraction of that figure per square foot.

Brickell Key now has three markets in one place. The first is presales at the Mandarin, the second is a developer buyout under negotiation at St. Louis, and the third is ordinary resales in the existing towers. Each one prices something different. The Mandarin's record shows what the brand and new construction are worth on this island, and it does not set the price of a 25-year-old three-bedroom next door.

The Top of the Ladder Is a Building Still Under Construction

Swire's October 1 release reports more than $1.7 billion in residential sales across both towers. More than $620 million of that came in 2026, including over $150 million in one three-month stretch this summer. Earlier this year, the two crown penthouses sold to separate buyers for $49.9 million each, at about $6,300 per square foot. Swire describes those sales as mainland Miami records for both condo price and price per square foot.

The project is two products. The 66-story South Tower has 228 private residences and was 80% sold as of October 1. The 33-story North Tower has 121 hotel rooms for what Mandarin Oriental calls its planned North American flagship, plus 70 private residences and 28 Hotel Collection residences. It reached 25% sold after its Signature Gallery opened in May. Remaining South Tower residences start at $7 million and remaining North Tower residences start at $4 million. Delivery is scheduled for 2030. Fortune Development Sales manages sales for the project exclusively. Our team works within the Fortune International group.

A $4 million minimum in the North Tower buys a hotel-serviced address. The release says North Tower owners get privileged access to the hotel's spa and waterfront dining, along with a dedicated Mandarin Oriental residential team. The South Tower's $7 million minimum buys the larger, more private residential building. Both prices are for new construction under one of the best-known hotel brands, delivered four years out.

What the Existing Towers Recorded This Summer

Deed records for July through September 2026 show four Brickell Key condo resales at $2 million or more. All four are large three-bedroom units in buildings completed between 1982 and 2008.

Address Year built Price Interior Per sq ft Recorded
520 Brickell Key Drive 1982 $2,550,000 2,542 sq ft $1,003 Sept. 1
900 Brickell Key Blvd 2008 $2,200,000 2,065 sq ft $1,065 Sept. 1
901 Brickell Key Blvd 2005 $2,323,000 2,591 sq ft $897 Sept. 4
808 Brickell Key Drive 1998 $2,200,000 2,510 sq ft $876 July 7

Building age barely moved the price. In this quarter's records, the 1982 tower sold at about the same price per square foot as the 2008 tower. The whole group sits between $876 and $1,065, which is about one-sixth of the Mandarin crown.

The mainland shows a different pattern over the same months. At 1425 Brickell Avenue, built in 2003, three resales recorded between $1,430 and $3,479 per square foot. At 300 Biscayne Boulevard Way, completed in 2024, six recorded resales ran from $1,306 to $1,611 per square foot. Across the river, older branded and newer buildings trade at a clear premium to Brickell Key's existing stock. On the island, a brand record is being set a few hundred feet from towers whose summer resales have stayed under $1,100 a foot.

St. Louis Puts a Developer's Price on an Older Building

The third price comes from 800 Claughton Island Drive. St. Louis is a 31-story, 134-unit building completed in 1995, with units from two to four bedrooms. In April, The Real Deal reported that Related Group and Terra were negotiating a buyout. It would likely exceed $1 million per unit, and one source put it closer to $1.5 million per unit, or roughly $200 million for the building. A group of nearly 80% of owners is negotiating, and sources said a deal could close in 2027. The same report said owners had been weighing a bulk sale for nearly two years, after an earlier unsolicited offer from another developer. It would be the first redevelopment of an existing condo building on Brickell Key since the island was built. In November, the same outlet described the building as still in the midst of that buyout.

The reported range is useful for its level. A figure of $1 million to $1.5 million per unit is an average across a whole building of two-, three- and four-bedroom homes. It falls below the $2.2 million to $2.55 million that four large three-bedroom units on the island recorded this summer. An average across a building and the price of one large unit are different measures. Even so, the reported offer does not put St. Louis anywhere near Mandarin pricing.

A developer looking at waterfront land next to the Mandarin site reportedly values it at a level close to what the existing condo market already pays. The premium belongs to the new building and its brand. The land under an older tower has not taken on Mandarin pricing just because it sits next door.

The Island's Shared Costs Sit Between the Two

Every owner on Brickell Key buys into two associations. One is their own building's association. The other is a master association that Swire has controlled since the island was first developed in the 1980s. The island has about 11 condo buildings and nearly 3,000 condos, along with ground-floor retail and the Courvoisier Centre offices.

In September 2025, the master association presented a plan to replace the seawall around the island, at an estimated total of about $42 million. Under that plan, a 600-square-foot unit would pay between $3,581 as a lump sum and $5,565 if financed. A 2,500-square-foot unit would pay between $14,921 and $20,319. The Real Deal reported those estimates in October 2025, and they were planning figures at that point. These figures are general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. Anyone weighing a purchase should confirm their own exposure with the appropriate professionals.

The plan then went to court. In May 2026, the Brickell Key One, Brickell Key Two, Isola, Courvoisier Courts and Carbonell associations sued Swire over a $32.3 million assessment for the seawall and baywalk work, which is called the Brickell Key Shoreline Resiliency Initiative. Swire has said it and the master association complied with the law. In November, St. Louis filed a separate suit against Swire entities and demolition contractor BG Group. The association cites roughly $276,000 in remediation after dust from the April implosion reached its air conditioning, pool and common areas. Swire said it had not been served, that it complied with all applicable safety rules, and that St. Louis declined its offers.

All of this bears on price. A buyer in an older tower takes on the building's own costs and a share of island-wide costs. For a large unit, the island-wide share in the 2025 plan amounted to a five-figure sum. A Mandarin buyer pays far more per square foot up front, for a building that will be new when the bills begin.

Four Years of Construction Is Part of the Price

Swire has scheduled delivery for 2030. St. Louis is the only building directly next to the site. Its association has told The Real Deal that cleanup costs have strained owners. The other towers sit farther away, but they are on the same 44-acre island.

The construction years also explain part of the gap between the summer resales and the Mandarin floor. Someone buying an existing island condo in 2026 is buying a finished home, with the island's largest construction project running nearby until it is done. Someone buying a Mandarin presale is paying today's price for the island as it will be in 2030. That includes a hotel that returns to 500 Brickell Key Drive and a 100,000-square-foot amenity podium serviced by Mandarin Oriental. The two buyers are on the same island and are paying for different years.

Choosing Where to Buy on the Island

A buyer comparing Brickell Key against other Brickell options this winter is really choosing among three prices. A resale in an existing tower recorded around $876 to $1,065 per square foot this summer. It comes with island-wide costs whose final amount is in litigation, and with construction next door until 2030. The St. Louis buyout shows that a developer values an older building's land at about the existing market's level. A Mandarin residence starts at $4 million in the North Tower or $7 million in the South Tower and carries the brand premium from the day the contract is signed.

The three prices have stayed apart. This summer's recorded resales show the Mandarin's record has not pulled up the existing towers, so the island's waterfront in an older building still trades at resale levels. A buyer who wants the brand and new construction pays the brand's price for them.

FAQ

Has the St. Louis buyout closed? No. The Real Deal reported in April 2026 that a deal could close in 2027, and in November it described the building as still in the midst of the buyout.

What do the remaining Mandarin residences cost? As of Swire's October 1, 2026 release, remaining South Tower residences start at $7 million and remaining North Tower residences start at $4 million.

When will The Residences at Mandarin Oriental, Miami be finished? Swire has scheduled completion for 2030.

On Brickell Key, the right residence depends on which of the island's three prices fits your plans and when you want to live there. The Cofresi Group represents branded new development and luxury resales, from The Residences at Mandarin Oriental to the towers across Brickell. For a private conversation about where your plans fit on the island, receive our exclusive listings and we will be in touch.

Work With Us

We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth.

Follow Me on Instagram